Should you buy a historic property in Connecticut?

On Behalf of | May 20, 2025 | Real Estate

If you’re drawn to a charming colonial or Victorian home in Connecticut, you’re not alone. Many buyers love the state’s historic architecture. But before you buy, it’s important to understand how owning a protected historic property can affect your budget and renovation plans.

The hidden costs behind historic charm

When you purchase a property listed on state or local historic registers, you’re buying both a home and a piece of history that comes with rules. Connecticut’s preservation laws mean you’ll face extra oversight when making changes to your property’s exterior and sometimes interior features.

These rules protect architectural details but can add 15-30% to renovation costs. Simple projects like replacing windows might require historic materials that cost three times more than standard options. Even painting might need approval if your home is in a historic district.

Tax benefits can offset higher expenses

The financial picture isn’t all challenging. Connecticut offers property tax freezes for fixed-up historic properties. This means your property taxes won’t go up due to improvements for up to 10 years in many towns.

The state also connects owners with grants and the Historic Homes Rehabilitation Tax Credit Program. The program can return 30% of renovation costs through tax credits for qualified projects over $15,000.

Consider your renovation temperament

 Beyond finances, think about your personality and vision for the property. Historic homeownership works best if you:

  • Value preservation and craftsmanship
  • Enjoy researching period-appropriate details
  • Have patience for approval processes
  • Can compromise on modern conveniences

If you dream of open floor plans and modern updates, a historic property might bring constant frustration.

Do your homework first 

Before committing, contact the local historic district commission where the property stands. Ask the commission about the following:

  •         The approval timelines
  •         The restrictions on purchasing historic property in the area
  •         The percentage of applications it approves

Their responsiveness gives insight into what you’ll face as an owner.

Talk with current owners of nearby historic properties about their experiences. Real stories provide perspective that regulations can’t show.

Making your decision

For some owners, the pride of preserving Connecticut’s architectural heritage outweighs the challenges. Others find the rules too limiting.

The best approach is to review your finances carefully and be honest with yourself. Weigh the higher costs against possible incentives, and ask whether you’ll welcome the oversight or find it frustrating.